Free second opinion on your roofing quote.
Already have a roofing quote — or were told 'you need a new roof' — from another contractor? Before you sign off on a major job, let a local, certified Tall Pines pro review it. We'll tell you honestly whether the work is truly needed, whether the scope and materials are right, and whether the price is fair. No pressure. No obligation.
Get your free second opinion
Tell us what the other contractor recommended and we'll take an honest look.
Why get a second opinion from Tall Pines
-
No Pressure, No Obligation
We give you our honest assessment of your existing quote. You decide what to do next — we never push.
-
Is the Work Really Needed?
Some homeowners are told they need a full replacement when the roof has good years left. We tell you the truth — we only sell roofs that are truly needed.
-
Is the Price Fair?
We review the scope and materials against fair local pricing — so you know before you sign a major roofing contract.
How it works
From your existing quote to an honest answer
Three easy steps — and no obligation to hire us at the end of any of them.
- 1
Send us the quote
Fill out the form with a few details about what the other contractor recommended. A photo of the written estimate or inspection report is perfect.
- 2
We review or re-inspect
A local, certified Tall Pines roofing pro reviews the exact scope and — when needed — takes a fresh look at your roof in person, at no charge.
- 3
You get an honest answer
We tell you whether the work is truly needed, whether the scope and materials are right, and whether the price is fair — yours to keep, no obligation.
Reassurance
Second opinion FAQs
Is the second opinion really free?
Yes. Reviewing the roofing quote or inspection you already received is free with no obligation. If an in-person re-inspection of your roof is needed for an accurate answer, we'll tell you up front — our roof inspections are provided at no charge.
What do you give a second opinion on?
Roofing only. If another contractor told you that you need a new roof, quoted a repair, or recommended a full tear-off and replacement, send it over. We review the scope, the materials and shingle grade, and the price so you can make a confident decision before you sign.
Do I really need a full roof replacement?
Not always. It's common for a roof to be quoted for a full replacement when a targeted repair, partial replacement, or maintenance would solve the problem and last for years. A free second opinion confirms whether the recommended work is genuinely needed — which often saves homeowners thousands of dollars.
Do I have to hire Tall Pines?
Not at all. The goal is to give you the truth so you can decide with confidence. If the other contractor's scope and price are fair, we'll tell you that too. We'd rather earn your trust than your business.
How do I know if my roofing quote is fair?
A fair roofing quote should clearly itemize the tear-off and disposal, the underlayment and ice-and-water shield, the shingle grade and manufacturer, flashing and ventilation, the permit, and labor — not just one lump sum. Pricing varies with your roof's size, pitch, number of layers to remove, and material choice. If a quote feels high or vague, send it over and a certified Tall Pines pro will give you a free, apples-to-apples review.
Can I email photos or the quote PDF?
Yes — and it helps. After you submit the form, email the written estimate, the inspection report, or photos of your roof to our team using the address in your confirmation, or have them ready for your call. The more we can see, the more precise our second opinion will be.
What areas does Tall Pines Roofing serve?
We serve homeowners throughout the Greater Rochester area and Monroe County, New York. If you're local and have a roofing quote in hand, we'll take an honest look.
Reviews
See what your neighbors say
We’d rather you hear it straight from Rochester homeowners than take our word for it. Watch them tell their stories on camera — or read real, unedited reviews on the platforms we can’t edit.
Have a roofing quote in hand? Let's take an honest look.
Get a free, no-pressure second opinion from a local, certified Rochester roofing team — and the confidence that you're making the right call at a fair price.