Roofing decision guides
Repair vs replace, shingle vs metal, and cost planning with upfront information.
How to use this hub
1. Learn
Start with our guides to understand the issue in plain language.
2. Evaluate
Compare options, tradeoffs, and cost drivers before requesting an estimate.
3. Act
Get a free estimate with context and ask sharper questions during your inspection.
How much does a roof replacement cost?
Open →How much does metal roofing cost?
Open →Roof repair vs replacement: how to decide
Repair makes sense when damage is localized, the roof is under 15 years old, and the deck is dry. Replace when shingles are widely worn, lea…
Open →Asphalt shingle vs standing seam metal roof
Asphalt shingles cost less upfront and suit most Rochester homes. Standing seam metal costs more but lasts longer, sheds snow well, and resi…
Open →Architectural vs 3-tab shingles
Architectural shingles are thicker, last longer, and carry higher wind ratings than flat 3-tab shingles for a modest cost increase. For most…
Open →Full tear-off vs roof-over
A full tear-off removes old shingles so we can inspect and fix the deck before installing new ones. A roof-over lays new shingles over the o…
Open →Should you file a storm-damage insurance claim?
File when documented storm damage clearly exceeds your deductible and the cause is sudden, not gradual wear. Skip it when the repair is mino…
Open →How to choose a roofer: red flags to avoid
A trustworthy roofer is licensed and insured, gives a written and itemized quote, is local with a real track record, and never pressures you…
Open →Why homeowners trust these guides
- We answer the questions homeowners actually ask — in plain English.
- Accurate, real-world advice on roofing, siding, gutters, and attic performance.
- Written for Greater Rochester homes — our weather, freeze-thaw winters, and older houses.
- Kept up to date, with clear next steps when you're ready to act.